A set built for different jobs, not duplicates
The Hand-Forged Carbon Steel Set from Smithey Ironware brings together four pieces: a Farmhouse skillet, a wok, an Oval Roaster, and a Rounder Roaster. Each is hand-forged in Charleston, SC, and pre-seasoned, so you can cook in it right away. The set is designed for cooks who want the performance of cast iron at a lighter weight, with the visual character of hand-hammered handles and a pre-seasoned interior finish.
Because the pieces are not identical, the first question is not which one to use first but which one fits the meal you have in mind. The skillet handles searing and frying, the wok is for stir-frying and tossing, and the two roasters are shaped for oven work. The supplied information does not specify exact dimensions or capacities for the roasters, so check those details if oven space or serving size is a deciding factor.
What the set includes
- The Hand-Forged Carbon Steel Set: Set includes a 12" Farmhouse skillet, a 13" Wok, an Oval Roaster, and a Rounder Roaster. Knowing the four pieces helps you plan first meals around the right pan rather than treating the set as one all-purpose tool.

The Hand-Forged Carbon Steel Set - The Hand-Forged Carbon Steel Set: Each piece is hand-forged in Charleston, SC, and pre-seasoned ready for use. Pre-seasoning means you can skip an initial seasoning project and start cooking, though the finish will continue to develop with use.
- The Hand-Forged Carbon Steel Set: The set offers performance that rivals cast iron at a lighter weight. Lighter weight matters for tossing, lifting, and moving between stovetop and oven, especially in a wok or large skillet.
How carbon steel compares with cast iron in this set
If you already cook with cast iron, the adjustment is mostly about weight and handling. Smithey describes the carbon steel as lighter than cast iron while still delivering comparable cooking performance. That makes the wok and skillet easier to lift and toss, and the roasters easier to move in and out of the oven. The trade-off is that carbon steel is not a nonstick coating; it relies on seasoning, just as cast iron does. The supplied care note says the pieces receive identical care as cast iron, so your existing cast iron routine is the right starting point.
One difference to keep in mind: the hand-forged construction means each piece is visually unique, with hand-hammered handles designed for grip. That is a cosmetic and tactile difference, not a performance claim. If you want a matched, uniform look across your kitchen, this set is intentionally not that. If you value the character of hand-forged cookware, it is a strong fit.
First meals to cook in each piece
- Farmhouse skillet: Use it for searing, frying, and skillet meals where you want a broad cooking surface. The pre-seasoned finish is ready for burgers, vegetables, or a simple breakfast.
- Wok: The wok is the piece for stir-frying and tossing. Its lighter weight compared with cast iron makes it easier to keep food moving over high heat.
- Oval Roaster: Shaped for oven roasting, it suits whole fish, vegetables, or cuts that benefit from an oval footprint. The supplied information does not specify dimensions, so check fit against your oven and rack.
- Rounder Roaster: Use it for rounder roasts, poultry, or oven-braised dishes. Like the Oval Roaster, its exact capacity is not listed in the supplied details, so confirm size if you plan to cook for a crowd.
Seasoning and care: start with your cast iron routine
The set arrives pre-seasoned, so there is no required first-use seasoning step in the supplied information. The care instruction is simply that the pieces receive identical care as cast iron. In practice, that means cleaning and maintaining the seasoning the way you already do for cast iron skillets and Dutch ovens. The supplied information does not include specific washing, drying, or re-seasoning procedures, so follow the care guidance that came with your cast iron or the manufacturer's documentation rather than inventing a new routine.
Because the pieces are hand-forged and limited in quantity, treat the seasoning as something that will develop with use rather than a factory finish that stays pristine. The pre-seasoned interior is a starting point, not a permanent coating. Avoid assuming the set is dishwasher-safe or that it can be left to soak; those details are not confirmed in the supplied information, and the safe default is the same care you give cast iron.
Is this set right for you?
The set makes the most sense if you want a coordinated group of hand-forged carbon steel pieces, value lighter weight than cast iron, and are comfortable maintaining seasoning. It is less suited if you want exact dimensional specifications before buying, need dishwasher-safe cookware, or prefer a uniform, machine-finished look. The catalog price is USD 595.00, compared with a catalog comparison price of USD 1190.00, so the set represents a meaningful bundle decision rather than a single-pan trial.
- Choose the set if: You want four distinct hand-forged pieces for stovetop and oven cooking, with the lighter weight and pre-seasoned finish described in the catalog.
- Choose individual pieces instead if: You only need one shape, or you want to confirm exact roaster dimensions and capacities before committing to the full set.
- Skip carbon steel if: You want a nonstick coating or dishwasher-safe cleanup. The supplied care note points to cast iron care, which is not the same as nonstick convenience.
What to confirm before you buy
The supplied product record lists the set contents and key construction details, but it does not include roaster dimensions, capacities, or a full care procedure. If those details affect your decision, check the product page or contact the store before ordering. The set is hand-forged and limited in quantity, so availability may vary. Once you have it, start with a simple meal in the skillet or wok, keep your cast iron care routine, and let the seasoning build from there.

